First, I want to say HAPPY BANNED BOOK WEEK to all! This is such an important week to readers because it is 100% about the freedom of choice – the choice to read. Most importantly, it is important that we continue to fight for this choice for all readers of all ages.
I am
proud to work with Book Journey this week and host this novel as well as a
giveaway.
When
I read the tweet to help celebrate, I knew immediately what novel I wanted to recognize
and host. At first I thought of Speak,
but then I decided on this one because I am always being asked what books I recommend
for male readers, especially reluctant ones, and I love this book that much and
cannot believe it has been challenged.
Title and author: The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian by Sherman Alexie
Pages: 230
ISBN: 9780316013697
Source: Purchased
Summary (from
book jacket):
Junior
is a budding cartoonist growing up on the Spokane Indian reservation. Born with
a variety of medical problems, he is picked on by everyone but his best friend.
Determined to receive a good education, Junior leaves the rez to attend an
all-white school in the neighboring farm town where the only other Indian is
the school mascot. Despite being condemned as a traitor to his people and
enduring great tragedies, Junior attacks life with wit and humor and discovers
a strength inside of himself that he never knew existed.
Inspired
by his own experiences growing up, award-winning author Sherman Alexie
chronicles the contemporary adolescence of one unlucky boy trying to rise above
the life everyone expects him to live.
My Thoughts:
Alexie
knocks it out of the park with this novel. He
introduces readers to Junior, a young boy who happens to be a walking miracle.
He was born with water on his brain, too many teeth, huge feet, and awful
eyesight. If that was not bad enough, he’s Native American too.
Throughout
the novel, readers are brought into a world unlike any other in YA literature. Readers will experience Junior’s frustration at the lack of equality in education on the
rez and will feel triumphant when he makes the decision to leave the rez for a
better education, even if that means betraying the one he respects the most, his
best friend.
Ultimately, this is a tale of survival. It’s hard to be a teenager, and when it seems that the world it out to “get you” in a variety of
ways, it adds to the headache.
But Junior keeps his head up, his hopes high, and his want for a better life center. From having a crush to fighting with a best friend to issues with teachers and family members, all readers will find themselves lost in the pages cheering for Junior.
But Junior keeps his head up, his hopes high, and his want for a better life center. From having a crush to fighting with a best friend to issues with teachers and family members, all readers will find themselves lost in the pages cheering for Junior.
Alexie's gift of storytelling is truly remarkable – he made me laugh and cry, many times
simultaneously, and he warmed my heart. Throughout the novel I found myself
rooting for Junior, no matter what it involved.
I
want to share with you one of my favorite moments in the novel. It’s one I
always share with my students when we study Alexie's essay, “Superman and Me.” To me,
this captures not only the tone of Junior’s life but it also will always be relevant
in society.
It
sucks to be poor, and it sucks to feel that you somehow deserve to be poor. You start believing that you’re poor because you’re stupid
and ugly. And then you start believing that you’re stupid and ugly because you’re
Indian. And because you’re Indian you start believing you’re destined to be
poor. It’s an ugly circle and there’s nothing you can do about it.
Poverty
doesn’t give you strength or teach you lessons about perseverance. No, poverty
only teaches you how to be poor (13).
It is
moments like these that make this worth your time. Alexie brings universal
truths to the forefront, challenging “ideas” many are raised to believe. With absolute tender care, Alexie provides readers a
look into what it truly is like to grow up not only poor in America but also
Native American. Stereotypes are addressed as well as being a growing, teenage boy.
But more than anything, this is always a “go to” novel for me with students,
especially male. I have not ever had a male student return the book and say he
did not like it. Usually when I ask all that is said is, “Can you recommend
another book I would like as well?”
Chris Crutcher enjoying BBW in Spokane |
And if that doesn't convince you...check out the picture of fellow author Chris Crutcher reading from the novel. A big THANK YOU to Kelly Milner Halls, his personal assistant, for allowing me to share the love and post this picture of Crutcher.
I
have read this novel and listened to it on audio – I recommend you do both. I recommend that you read the novel first. The cartoons that
accompany are an important element, but once you’ve read it, it is worth a
listen because Alexie is the reader.
Reasons given for banning this novel:
- offensive language
- racism
- religious viewpoint
- sexually explicit
- unsuited to age group
- "Northwest novel removed from Richland schools' reading list" - June 11, 2011
- "Banning Sherman Alexie Does Not Help Students" - June 27, 2011
- "Banned Books Week: Top 10 Most Challenged Titles of 2011" - October 1, 2012
- "About Banned and Challenged Books" - ALA
And now...it's GIVEAWAY time! Enter for your chance to win a copy of Sherman Alexie's YA novel below.
To Kill a Mockingbird is my favorite banned book because of the memorable story and the beautifully portrayed characters who live on. saubleb(at)gmail(dot)com
ReplyDeleteFor most of my juniors, it remains one of their favorite reads ever while in school.
DeleteI just finished reading The Color of Earth and I loved it!
ReplyDeleteKendal
@kstegmann
Kinx's Book Nook
I haven't read that - I will have to add it to my list.
DeleteGone With the Wind is my favorite.
ReplyDelete@CarolAnnM
Swoon!!! Such a great read - and rarely mentioned during BBW
DeleteI loved this book so much when I borrowed it from the library a year ago. I agree with you - there is so much "fantastic" about it! Thanks for being a part of banned book week -
ReplyDeleteAND my favorite banned books are the Harry Potter books.
twitter: bookjourney
You had me at Harry Potter, period. Such a fan - and I am shocked to learn that many of my high school juniors have no idea that (1) the books are banned and (2) banned books is a real thing.
DeleteIt still shocks me - until we talk about it and I have to educate them. But isn't that why we have school librarians as well? Shouldn't they celebrate a student's right to read?
To Kill A Mockingbird is my favorite :) Thanks for a great giveaway!
ReplyDeleteTwitter: @poshpow
Such a great choice - and a favorite among my students
DeleteTo Kill a Mockingbird is my all time favorite banned book :)
ReplyDeleteHappy Banned Book Week to you too! I've been wanting to read Part Time Indian!
@jenhartling
DeleteI'd say my current favorite is The Perks of Being a Wallflower. I've heard great things about The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian. It's been on my TBR list for a while, but I haven't read it yet. I keep seeing so many posts on it for Banned Book Week so I'm much more inclined to pick it up sooner rather than later. Lovely review.
ReplyDeletetwitter handle @kristiluvsbooks
Perks is such a great read - I read it because a student bought it for me and said, "You have to read this book." LOVED it!!!
DeleteMy favorite are Harry Potter series.
ReplyDelete@forestofthedead
A favorite of mine as well - love Harry Potter!!! One of the only series I will pick up and read again and again...as well as the audios
DeleteOne of my favorite banned books is THE COLOR PURPLE. It's heart breaking & beautifully written.
ReplyDelete(No Twitter)
marypres(AT)gmail(DOT)com
100% agree - I always recommend this novel when students choose an outside reading novel to work through and present to the class. I usually have a student who is familiar with the movie but never knew it was a book.
DeleteOne of my favorites is The Lord of the Flies. I think it has an amazingly powerful message. I wish it had been part of my HS curriculum!
ReplyDeleteKelly
@TheWRRedhead
Taught Lord of the Flies last year for the first time - I was shocked to learn that it was a banned book, and then again not so much. My seniors love, love, love that book. It's one thing they look forward to during the semester.
DeleteIsn't it weird that at the high school where I teach almost all of the novels we teach are on the banned list but our librarian doesn't discuss banned books at all. Students usually find out from the teachers instead.
One of several books that has popped up several times, I'm becoming more and more intrigued by this.
ReplyDeleteit is worth your time!
DeleteThe Awakening by Kate Chopin!
ReplyDelete@Jkimmelf
I was just talking about this book to my juniors because I teach "The Story of an Hour" by Chopin - we teach it in our AP Lit. class. I love hearing the comments from the boys when they read it.
DeleteSuch a great choice!
I've heard a lot of great things about this book so I've been meaning to read it, I've just got this towering TBR pile to read through. My favourite is The Perks of Being a Wallflower, I love the characters and writing. Thank you!
ReplyDeleteSwoon for 'Perks' - my juniors love that book!
DeleteMy favourite banned book is Brave New World by Aldous Huxley because it's so shocking to see how much of his book has come true even though it was written years ago. Plus, I love the way he writes & I love a good sci-fi book. =)
ReplyDeleteTwitter: @khal_khaleesi
x
I'm surprised I haven't seen this one listed more...great choice!
DeleteI love banned books week. I get all kinds of great recommendations every year. This is a new one to add to the old favorites!
ReplyDelete